Comments on: Back to the story of Taloot http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/ Just another Hadithuna weblog Thu, 20 Nov 2008 23:33:23 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.3.3 By: Hameed http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/#comment-343 Hameed Fri, 19 Oct 2007 11:32:25 +0000 http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/#comment-343 Thanks for this information on your knowledge on this subject. My question is, that Talut and Saul were two different people, however Christians say that the story related in the Quran about Talut, was in actual fact the story of Saul. Can you clarify ? Thanks for this information on your knowledge on this subject.

My question is, that Talut and Saul were two different people, however Christians say that the story related in the Quran about Talut, was in actual fact the story of Saul.

Can you clarify ?

]]> By: Hafsa http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/#comment-221 Hafsa Fri, 08 Jun 2007 02:16:14 +0000 http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/#comment-221 assalamu alaykum Br. Yaser. Jazak Allahu Khairan Katheeran for the post. I'm looking forward to al-Tabary and ibn Katheer! assalamu alaykum Br. Yaser. Jazak Allahu Khairan Katheeran for the post.

I’m looking forward to al-Tabary and ibn Katheer!

]]> By: Ayman Khafagi http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/#comment-69 Ayman Khafagi Thu, 08 Feb 2007 09:37:42 +0000 http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/#comment-69 p.s. and I took your advice and I am blogging :) p.s. and I took your advice and I am blogging :)

]]> By: Ayman Khafagi http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/#comment-68 Ayman Khafagi Thu, 08 Feb 2007 08:17:43 +0000 http://yaser.hadithuna.com/back-to-the-story-of-taloot/#comment-68 very enlightening actually. I am curious to read Ibn Ashour's tafseer :) I always wondered when I read the story of Taloot in Quran; why did they ask for a king. Now it is clear. The question now is; did Allah agree with them that it was thier governance system that failed them or He only wanted to make the point thru giving them what they asked for but in a different way (gave them a king but chose him based on different merits). very enlightening actually. I am curious to read Ibn Ashour’s tafseer :)
I always wondered when I read the story of Taloot in Quran; why did they ask for a king. Now it is clear. The question now is; did Allah agree with them that it was thier governance system that failed them or He only wanted to make the point thru giving them what they asked for but in a different way (gave them a king but chose him based on different merits).

]]>